Fourth edition, Nov 17 2026. From police open data, Census, FBI and BJS sources. Rankings are among cities with identifiable data.
Highest rate: among 14 cities whose police use a code that names mail or package theft, Austin had the highest 2025 rate, 269.5 reports per 100,000 residents, and New York City recorded the most reports, 16,361.
Holiday peak: in the city series with at least 150 reports a year, November and December held 20.4% to 25.4% of yearly reports, against 16.7% for an even spread, and December was the peak month in 15 of 18 series.
Hotspots: in the 10 Tier A cities with a reliable map, the top 10% of map cells held 24% to 42% of mapped 2026 reports.
Growth against e-commerce: in the 9 cities with comparable 2021 to 2025 series, police-recorded reports rose 24.5% (the rate rose 21.7%), while Census e-commerce sales rose 31.7%.
National estimate: about 380,000 to 2.2 million porch and mail thefts a year in the United States, with a midpoint near 810,000, a Lighthouse estimate built from police rates, Census population and the BJS share of theft reported to police, not an official count.
Few cities can be measured: only 14 of 26 places in the Index have a police code that names mail or package theft and is used consistently; Philadelphia, Memphis and Tulsa publish no package-specific series, and Los Angeles, Baltimore and Colorado Springs are shown but not ranked.
Search interest: Google Trends search interest for stolen package terms peaks every November and December, 1.45 to 2.38 times the January to October level in 2022 to 2025, but it does not track police-reported rates across the 14 ranked cities (Spearman 0.09).
Law: 26 states have a law that reaches packages from private carriers, and a $100 package taken from a porch on a first offense is a felony in 11 states.
Cite: Lighthouse Home Security. (2026). Lighthouse Home Security Porch Piracy Index 2026 [Data set; Fourth edition, Nov 17 2026]. https://lighthousehomesecurity.com/guides/porch-piracy-laws-statistics/ License: CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Reuse the data and charts with credit to Lighthouse Home Security Porch Piracy Index 2026 and a link to https://lighthousehomesecurity.com/guides/porch-piracy-laws-statistics/. Press contact: Nate Jeo, nate@pearl27.com ยท next edition planned for November 2027.